Human behavioral factors influencing biosecurity compliance: Evidence from an Experimental Game
Conference Year
January 2019
Abstract
Livestock disease costs U.S. industries over a billion dollars annually. Yet measures to reduce the likelihood of acquiring a disease are frequently treated as unnecessary, a waste of time or are simply ignored. These measures, also known as biosecurity practices, are designed to respond to and reduce the impact of a disease outbreak, or to reduce the likelihood of disease incidence. We sought to examine messaging factors that could impact decisions to comply with on-premise biosecurity practices. To accomplish this, we used a computer simulation that was played as an experimental game in which participants acted as workers in a swine facility. Our game simulated a conflict where participants were confronted with a decision whether to comply with a common biosecurity practice: a “line of separation” at which workers shower and change clothing before entering or exiting areas with animals. This line of separation is considered highly effective for reducing the risk of disease infection. Use of a shower facility, however, carries opportunity costs associated with the time needed for its use, which can result in workers electing to bypass or only partially implement this practice. Here we show how compliance is influenced by message delivery methodology with numeric, linguistic, and graphical messages showing increasing efficacy, respectively. Moreover, increased situational uncertainty and increased risk are correlated with increases in compliance. These results provide insight towards developing more effective messages that will allow managers of livestock facilities and policy makers to nudge behavior towards more disease resilient systems via greater compliance with biosecurity practices.
Primary Faculty Mentor Name
Scott Merrill
Faculty/Staff Collaborators
Scott C. Merrill, Susan Moegenburg, Christopher J. Koliba, Asim Zia, Eric Clark, Gabriela Bucini, Serge Wiltshire, Timothy Sellnow, Deanna Sellnow(Co-Authors) and Julia M. Smith(Co-Author and Principal Investigator)
Status
Graduate
Student College
College of Engineering and Mathematical Sciences
Program/Major
Complex Systems
Primary Research Category
Social Sciences
Secondary Research Category
Engineering & Physical Sciences
Human behavioral factors influencing biosecurity compliance: Evidence from an Experimental Game
Livestock disease costs U.S. industries over a billion dollars annually. Yet measures to reduce the likelihood of acquiring a disease are frequently treated as unnecessary, a waste of time or are simply ignored. These measures, also known as biosecurity practices, are designed to respond to and reduce the impact of a disease outbreak, or to reduce the likelihood of disease incidence. We sought to examine messaging factors that could impact decisions to comply with on-premise biosecurity practices. To accomplish this, we used a computer simulation that was played as an experimental game in which participants acted as workers in a swine facility. Our game simulated a conflict where participants were confronted with a decision whether to comply with a common biosecurity practice: a “line of separation” at which workers shower and change clothing before entering or exiting areas with animals. This line of separation is considered highly effective for reducing the risk of disease infection. Use of a shower facility, however, carries opportunity costs associated with the time needed for its use, which can result in workers electing to bypass or only partially implement this practice. Here we show how compliance is influenced by message delivery methodology with numeric, linguistic, and graphical messages showing increasing efficacy, respectively. Moreover, increased situational uncertainty and increased risk are correlated with increases in compliance. These results provide insight towards developing more effective messages that will allow managers of livestock facilities and policy makers to nudge behavior towards more disease resilient systems via greater compliance with biosecurity practices.